Matt writes:
…You know what? These verses (and all the others about speech inviting a beating, or your words being like a nuclear bomb, laying waste to all in their path) apply even if you didn’t mean what the listener heard. And you know what else? You can’t just fall back on “well, that’s not what I meant” because regardless, a person was hurt by your words…
(You should probably read the rest of his post so my response makes at least some sense)
Since I am familiar with this particular situation, allow me to offer some insight. Firstly, Prov. 26:18-19 doesn’t apply. Shame on you for using it out of context. No one DECEIVED a neighbor, nor did anyone say that they were joking.
As far as the body of the blog, in this particular situation, those verses (probably) apply, because your (and my) speech was not building up others, and was, in fact, fairly negative. I would like to examine this on a more general level, though, not just one that is specific to a particular event. Let me offer a hypothetical.
Suppose that after a U2 concert, upon meeting the band, I say to the Edge, “I really enjoyed your playing tonight, I thought it was wonderful.” If Bono overhears these comments, he may think to himself, “He complimented Edge, but not me, he must think I am a terrible singer,” and he is thus offended/hurt by my speech (hey, I said it was a hypothetical, and I wasn’t kidding).
According to your blog, I am at fault. I vehemently disagree with that assessment. Words have meaning, and we absolutely should NOT be held accountable for the thoughts/actions of others when our thoughts/actions were completely pure. If someone ignores the meaning of my words (this includes context), the fault is not mine, but theirs. I realize, again, that this is a big hypothetical (on a myriad of levels), and it is a rare instance when someone can say that my behavior in a situation was 100% pure; however, I think some critical analysis exposes a gaping fundamental hole in your statements. So there
.
With THAT said, I, also, would like to apologize anyone whom I may have offended, especially in specific recent incidents. I feel rotten. And a personal apology will be made, but I don’t want anyone to misread this as belligerence on my part, because that is not the case at all. I’m sorry.
